Jinan United Perfect Building Materials Corporation
Jinan United Perfect Building Materials Corporation
Gold Verified Supplier
1Yr
Verified Business License Business License
Main Products: Aluminum foil composite, Roofing & Walling Waterproofing materials, fiberglass fabric/ tissue, Insulation & Acoustic materials
Home > Blog > Synthetic Underlayment vs Felt and Ice and Water Shield

Contact Us

Mr. Du
Sales Director
Chat Now

Your inquiry content must be between 10 to 5000 characters

Please enter Your valid email address

Please enter a correct verification code.

Synthetic Underlayment vs Felt and Ice and Water Shield

A builder in North America once treated a roof with a single underlayment over the whole area and had water appear at an eave after a freeze and thaw. The sheet had shed the rain and had not resisted the ice, which was the job of a different product that had not been specified.

A roof underlayment comparison usually sets a synthetic underlayment against felt, and the third product in the comparison is often left out. An ice and water shield is not an alternative to either of them: it is a self-adhering membrane for the details, and the three products sit in different places on the same roof. This article compares the synthetic underlayment versus felt on the properties that matter and explains where an ice and water shield belongs alongside them.

1. Synthetic Underlayment Versus Felt: The Materials

A synthetic underlayment versus felt comparison is a comparison between a polymer sheet and a saturated organic felt, and the two made from different materials behave differently.

Felt is a mat of organic fibres, usually paper-based, saturated with asphalt. The asphalt provides the water resistance and the fibres provide the mat, and the two age together as the asphalt oxidises.

A synthetic underlayment is a woven or non-woven polymer sheet, usually polypropylene or a polyester composite, with a coating applied to one or both faces. The water resistance comes from the polymer and the coating, and the strength comes from the fibre structure.

PropertyFeltSynthetic
BaseOrganic fibres, asphaltPolymer fibres, coating
AgeingBrittle as asphalt oxidisesRetains flexibility
Weight per squareHeavyLight
Tear resistanceLowHigh
Surface frictionHigherLower
Exposure periodShortLonger

The two materials also fail in different ways. Felt cracks and splits, usually at a change of plane or where it has been walked on. A synthetic sheet tears at a fastener or a cut edge, and it slips rather than cracks where the surface is slick.

The failure mode matters for the choice. A roof where the underlayment is exposed for a long period before the covering favours the material that keeps its flexibility, and a roof where the crew is used to felt needs attention to the change in surface friction.

2. Roof Underlayment Comparison Differences on Site

The differences that matter on site are the ones that appear during installation and during the exposure period rather than on paper.

The tear resistance is the first. A synthetic underlayment resists a tear that starts at a fastener or at a cut edge, so it survives the traffic of an installation that would start a split in a felt.

Site ConditionFeltSynthetic
Walking on the sheetCan tear or splitResists
Fastener at the edgeTear startsTear resists
Long exposureDegradesRated period
Footing on a slopeBetter gripSlicker
Roll handlingTwo-personOne-person

The exposure period is the second. A synthetic sheet is rated for a longer period, which gives the roofing programme more room between wrapping the deck and installing the covering. That is a schedule benefit rather than a performance benefit, and it is often the reason a contractor makes the change.

The surface friction is the difference that works against the synthetic sheet. Felt offers more grip and a synthetic sheet is slicker, particularly when damp. On a steep roof, or on a morning with dew, that difference changes how the work has to be done.

3. Where an Ice and Water Shield Belongs

An ice and water shield belongs at the details, and it is specified in addition to the field underlayment rather than instead of it.

The shield is a self-adhering membrane that bonds to the deck and seals around a fastener. It is used where water can back up under the covering rather than run off, which occurs at the eaves when ice forms, in a valley where two slopes meet, and around the penetrations.

LocationWhy the Shield
EavesIce can back up under the covering
ValleysWater concentrates from two slopes
PenetrationsSelf-seals around a fastener
Ridges and hipsWind-driven water entry
Low-slope areasSlow drainage, ponding risk

The shield differs from a field underlayment in two ways. It bonds to the deck rather than lying over it, so water cannot travel beneath it, and it seals around a fastener rather than relying on the lap and the cap. Those two properties are what allow it to resist water that is being pushed upward rather than running down.

The shield is usually laid before the underlayment courses reach the detail, so that the field sheet laps over the shield rather than the other way round. The order of the two layers follows the direction of the water.

4. A Roof Underlayment Comparison Across the Three

A roof underlayment comparison across all three products shows that they occupy different parts of the roof rather than competing for the same one.

The synthetic underlayment covers the field, the felt is a legacy alternative in the same position, and the shield protects the details. A roof normally carries two of the three: a field sheet and a shield.

ProductPositionFunction
Synthetic underlaymentFieldShed water at the laps
FeltField, legacyShed water at the laps
Ice and water shieldDetailsResist backed-up water

The comparison should therefore be made in two parts. The field choice is between the synthetic sheet and the felt, and the detail choice is a shield in addition to whichever field sheet is used. A roof underlayment comparison that stops at the field has compared two of the three products and left out the one that protects the detail.

A specification that names one product for the whole roof has left out the detail that protects the eaves and the valleys, and that omission is the one that appears as a leak after a freeze.

5. Case Notes on Roof Underlayment Comparison Choices

A builder in North America covered a roof with a single felt layer over the whole area and had water appear at an eave after a freeze and thaw. The felt had shed the rain and had not resisted the ice, which was the duty of the shield that had not been specified. Adding a shield at the eaves and in the valleys removed the leak, and the field felt was unchanged.

A second project used a synthetic underlayment over the whole roof, including the valleys, and found the laps lifting at the valley after a wind. The valley needed a shield rather than a field sheet, and the field sheet had been applied where a bonded membrane was required. Adding the shield at the valley and lapping the field sheet over it corrected the detail.

Both cases show the same point. The field sheet and the detail shield do different jobs, and treating one as a substitute for the other leaves the detail unprotected.

6. Choosing Between Felt and Synthetic

Choose a synthetic underlayment where the roof will be exposed for a period, where the crew will walk the surface, or where the covering will be delayed.

Choose felt where a legacy specification requires it, where a short length is needed for a repair, or where the local market still supplies it at a material advantage and the roof will be covered quickly.

Choose the shield at the eaves, the valleys and the penetrations in every case, whatever the field sheet. The two decisions are separate, and the second one is not affected by the first.

State the field sheet and the shield as separate line items, so that the detail is not lost in a single underlayment entry.

7. Specifying Underlayment and Ice and Water Shield

State the field underlayment by weight, tensile strength, tear resistance and exposure period, and state the lap width and the fastening pattern.

State the shield by its adhesion and its service temperature range, and name the locations where it is required. A shield named as a product without its locations is likely to be applied at the eaves and omitted from the valleys.

State the order of the layers, with the field sheet lapping over the shield. The order follows the direction of the water, and reversing it places the shield above the field sheet where it no longer protects the detail.

State the exposure period for the field sheet, and confirm that it covers the period between wrapping and covering. That figure is a schedule constraint and should be checked against the programme rather than assumed.

8. Synthetic Underlayment and Shield Supplier Profile

United Perfect Building Materials, part of Jinan United Perfect Building Materials Corporation, produces synthetic roofing underlayment for residential and commercial roofs and supplies buyers in North America. The company quotes the weight, tensile strength, tear resistance and exposure period of each grade, which allows a roof underlayment comparison to be made on stated figures.

Jinan United Perfect Building Materials holds retained samples by production batch, so a delivered roll can be checked against the reference used at approval. Buyers comparing a synthetic underlayment versus felt can confirm the exposure period and the tear resistance in writing, and can order the shield for the details together with the field sheet from one source. United Perfect can also advise on the lap order where a shield is used at a valley.

9. FAQ About Underlayment and Ice and Water Shield

9.1 Is a synthetic underlayment better than felt?

It performs differently rather than better in every respect, and the differences favour the synthetic sheet for most modern roofs. A synthetic underlayment resists tearing at a fastener, keeps its flexibility over a longer period and is rated for a longer exposure, which suits a roof that is walked on and covered later. Felt is heavier, offers more grip underfoot and remains adequate for a quick cover. The synthetic underlayment versus felt choice therefore depends on the exposure period and the traffic.

9.2 Does an ice and water shield replace the underlayment?

No, and the two occupy different parts of the roof. An ice and water shield is a self-adhering membrane used at the eaves, in the valleys and around the penetrations, where water can back up under the covering. The field underlayment covers the general area and sheds water at the laps, so a roof normally carries both, with the field sheet lapping over the shield at each detail. The shield is an addition to the field underlayment rather than an alternative for the whole roof.

9.3 Why does a shield resist backed-up water?

Because it bonds to the deck rather than lying over it, and it seals around a fastener rather than relying on a lap and a cap. Water that is pushed upward by ice or that collects in a valley cannot travel beneath a shield that is bonded to the deck, and it cannot enter at a fastener that the membrane has sealed around. A field underlayment depends on the lap and the drainage path, which works for water running down and not for water being pushed up.

9.4 Which order are the layers installed?

The shield is laid first at each detail, and the field underlayment laps over it. That order follows the direction of the water, so that anything running down the field reaches the shield and is carried away rather than running behind it. Reversing the order places the shield above the field sheet, where it no longer protects the detail and can even trap water at the lap. The order should be stated in the specification rather than left to the crew.

9.5 Can I use felt and a shield together?

Yes, and that combination was common before synthetic sheets became the default. The shield protects the eaves, the valleys and the penetrations, and the felt covers the field. The combination remains adequate for a roof that will be covered quickly, and it loses the tear resistance and the longer exposure period of a synthetic sheet. Where the roof will be walked on, or where the covering will be delayed past the felt's rated exposure, the field sheet is the element that is worth changing rather than the shield.

Share

Contact Us

Send Inquiry to Us
* Message
0/5000

Want the best price? Post an RFQ now!

Recommended Products